Was Eli stressed because he now could no longer hold his two rings over Peyton’s head? No.
Was Eli thinking heavily because his own team had suffered so many late game losses that he knew more than anyone that the game wasn’t over by then? And maybe he was just trying to plan out what he would do in his Brother’s shoes. Maybe that’s also why Cooper just looks relieved and we can’t quite tell if Archie is smiling or not but he doesn’t jump up and down like anyone else.
Did Eli just suddenly realize he left his oven on? No
Was Eli just kind of relieved and has resting derp face? No. (Well, …yes, that’s probably the right answer)
Eli just wanted his ice cream.