The Saints Get Their Wish
There is a certain poetry to the Saints getting screwed over by a terrible rule/call in week one to getting the correct call also going against them in week 3. Not for Saints fans, of course, but for the rest of us. Saints fans demanded justice after week one. They craved proper officiating. They got it, and Tyler Shough died for the cause.
I want to take the rest of this post to put forth a bold proposal: If the ball is still in the QB’s hands when contacted, it’s a fumble. None of this “arm going forward” debate. If the ball is still within the grip of the QB when contacted and lost, that’s it. Fumble. No more “intent”. Just basic fact. If the ball left the QB’s grip without direct intent of release, that shit is a fumble.
I hate the arm going forward thing. Throwing motions are not divided into neat sections where you can directly point to the arm coming forward. The entire throwing motion is one fluid process with a number of overlapping phases. The elbow comes forward while the forearm is still moving up or back, etc etc. The replays tend to put the dividing line as the elbow starting to go forward but it’s a grey area up to interpretation and I’ve seen what I thought were clear fumbles called as passes and clear forward motion called fumbles. When the arm is at the midpoint of the windup, the call is just vibes. That’s why I want this to change.
Will this result in more fumbles? Yes. I don’t care. I’m tired of the ambiguity. Make it clear. If that ball leaves the QBs hands for any other reason than the QB let it go, FUMBLE.


Honestly, I’d be fine if they went even less technical on it. Did the ball travel forward in the air past the LOS, or maybe did the ball move forward X yards in the air? If so, it was a pass attempt. If not, fumble. No debating the motion, just make it some sort of easily measurable metric where sometimes it’s going to result in awful turnovers; but it would be consistent, which would be a breath of fresh air for NFL officiating.
That’s how it works in high school. The question in high school is simply “what direction was the ball traveling when it left the passers hand?”
Agreed. A fumble is more interesting as it has a high chance of turnover.
I’ve said this unpopular opinion before and I’ll say it again: instant replay is ruining sports.
Instead of arguing about the judgement of officials or what happened on the field, which are reasonable things to argue about, we now all have to be lawyers and argue about the minute nuances in the rule book. Instead of being viscerally excited when our team scores a touchdown, we stop and wait 3 minutes to make sure he really did cross the goal line. If he didn’t, we just wait one play for him to score in a tush push instead. Spectacular athletic plays get overturned because of slight movements of the ball that can’t be seen with the naked eye but can at 3000 fps.
It’s even worse in other sports. In hockey, we get an exciting and suspenseful sustained attack leading to a goal that gets overturned because 2 minutes ago the guy was 1/4″ offside.
The rare case where a truly impactful call gets blown and changes the course of a game isn’t worth the cost to the overall experience.
I was just complaining to my 11yo over the weekend that I miss the days when you could watch a game, and game scores just didn’t exist on the screen. At a commercial break, they would *sometimes* give you the score update pf the game you were watching, but it wasn’t a guarantee. And if you wanted to know what the score in OTHER games were? You’d have to wait for the halftime show or the postgame wrap.
I think the hyper-focused redzone-style every-second-update has definitely ruined my enjoyment. Instead of having my curiosity drive what’s happening, it all just flashes in front of my eyes, nonstop.
And for me, yea, I’d roll the replay up under that. We can see every angle, in slow motion. There’s really nothing to argue anymore BUT the rules. It’s too easy to see exactly what happened from 15 angles. Instead of just throwback uniforms, they should do throwback presentations. If a team is wearing their 80s style jerseys, the broadcast should go 80s style, and the replays should reflect what they did in the 80s. If they wear 50s era jerseys, make the presentation b&w, and it’s a free-for-all. XD
Want to make the Hall of Fame preseason game more exciting? Take your 50s style idea and implement it for that game. 😀
As someone who loves the nerdy side of football, in both formations and the littlelest techiniques they do, it would have never been possible without instant replay
> If the ball is still in the QB’s hands when contacted, it’s a fumble. None of this “arm going forward” debate. If the ball is still within the grip of the QB when contacted and lost, that’s it. Fumble.
Meh. I agree that there should be objective criteria, but I don’t think that should be it. If a QB manages to throw the ball 10+ yards while being pulled down, if the ball hits the ground, should that be a fumble?
> Make it clear. If that ball leaves the QBs hands for any other reason than the QB let it go, FUMBLE.
“QB let it go” is still kind of subjective. How do you distinguish between “let it go” and “lost”?
I think a simpler metric would be if the ball moves forward, it’s a forward pass. If that would result in too *few* fumbles, then require that the ball move forward past the line of scrimmage or something.
Honestly I think the requirement it needs to be past the LoS would fix it with the caveat of letting behind the LoS ones not count if the balls within a yard of an eligible receiver.
There hasn’t been any controversy with the pass vs fumble calls except when specific rules get involved that have no reason to exist in the first place. Think the tuck rule, and this “intent to throw” one. Just keep it simple, forwards throws are passes, anything else is a fumble. Passes that go backwards because a defender turned the QBs arm around are still backwards passes
Also the “process rule”. I think Lions fans were going to fight the refs over that one.
the Saints deserve any and all bad fortune until the Vikings win a Super Bowl to restore the karmic balance.
This also extends to the Broncos or any other team as long as they employ Sean Payton
This. Exactly. Skol.
It would be less obnoxious if Shough’s arm hadn’t actually been moving forward. They dicked up the call both times. Yay refs!
So… Drake Maye didnt fumble then? 🙂
A little late on this, but noticed you said “No more intent” and “If the ball left the QB’s grip without direct INTENT of release, that shit is a fumble.” in the same paragraph. That’s probably part of why this is so hard to officiate. If we went by every time the QB’s arm got hit when throwing before the ball leaves, there would be WAY more fumbles, many of which are obvious forward passes that happen to be thrown off just slightly.