I was surprised to discover this past week that Tuanon remains active. Just like the actual conspiracy movement the Tua fan collective is named for that sort of just faded from public consciousness after a point, I sort of expected Tuanon to have done the same over the past couple of seasons.

I went searching on twitter (my first mistake, yes) to try and find a clip of the latest Tua brain fart against the Bills and was immediately bombarded with posts complaining about how Herbert got bailed out or whatever by Tuanon posters who are still, still, somehow on that train. He’s just a football player at what point do you move the fuck on? Why is Herbert still this object of such obsession? He’s just his own guy, doing his own thing, over on the opposite coast.

Granted, I do believe the Tuanon movement has slowed and shrunk. It had to. When I made the original Tuanon comic, Tua was hot shit and Herbert had stalled. Two years later, Herbert is making strides and continuing his good play while Tua has…broken.

The Dolphins offense went from explosive titan captained by Lord Tagovailoa into a mess that crumbled the instant Tua was out, into a rudderless wreck that barely functions at times even with Tua still healthy and in. I know it’s not all Tua’s fault, but the fall has been drastic.

He’s developed a nickname that a lot of Dolphins fans seethe at: Tua Turndaballova. I want to say it’s a stupid nickname but he’s been earning it. In each game this year, from the thumping by the Colts, the mess against the Patriots, and the valiant failed effort against the Bills, Tua has thrown a terrible ball directly to a defender.

Look at the Colts pass. It’s like he’s completely blind to the defender sitting right in the passing lane. Maybe he thought he had more zip on this arm? While he’s out of the pocket, there’s no pressure, he had time to survey the field. It was the most embarrassing throw on a day full of them.

The Patriots pass isn’t much better. Tua is actually under pressure this time, so you can attribute this one at least partially to panic, but I have no idea what the hell he is trying to accomplish with this pass. The guy you are throwing to isn’t close to open, and that’s ignoring the defender DIRECTLY IN YOUR LINE OF SIGHT. That’s a ball you either run with or throw away. Terrible decision. A veteran QB this deep into his career should not be making this kind of panic toss.

The Bills pass was the cherry on top. A play I literally called in my discord chat about 2 quarters before it happened. It was another terrible decision. It’s a quick read and a quick throw, so it’s isn’t caused by pressure. However, Tua stares down his target the entire time and throws a ball the defender easily steps in front of. It effectively ended the game. 0-3 Dolphins.

I didn’t want to make the usual joke that his brain has holes and is full of CTE because that seemed like the cheap way to do it but it is really hard to not wonder sometimes. Intelligence was supposed to be one of Tua’s strengths. He’s getting worse. The Dolphins are financially tied to him for the time being so they have to try to make it work, but oof. Something has to change, or he’s going to end up another what-if. At least he got his bag already.